Their neighbour has their spare key and you barely know them

3 minute read. Updated November 16, 2026.

Someone has a spare key to their home, or was feeding the cat, and you barely know them. This guide walks you through the first conversation, getting the key back, and the useful things that person may know and you do not.


Start with a short, friendly conversation

Reach out soon, but keep it light. A phone call or a knock at the door is fine. Say who you are and how you are connected. Thank them for whatever they have been doing, because they probably have been helping without being asked.

Then say what you need. You want to collect the key, and you would like to hear anything they know about the house, the pets or the routines. Keep the first conversation short. You can always talk again once you have had time to think.

If they seem unsure about handing things over, do not push. Ask when would suit them, and offer to come to them.

Get the key back, and check what else they hold

Ask for the key in person if you can. It is easier to be clear, and you can see the key and any fob or code that goes with it. If they live far away, ask them to post it by a tracked method, or arrange for someone nearby to collect it.

While you are there, ask about anything else that opens the house or the garden. Spare keys, garage remotes, gate codes, alarm codes, a key safe combination. People often hold more than one thing and forget the rest.

If a key cannot be found, or you are not sure how many copies exist, it is reasonable to have the locks changed. That is a practical decision, not a comment on the neighbour.

What they might know that you do not

A neighbour or friend who has been in the house often sees things family does not. They may know where the stopcock is, which window sticks, when the bins go out, and which tradesperson has been reliable. They may know the cat's hiding places, the vet's name, or that the boiler needs topping up.

They may also know about people. Who visits, who has been unwell, which friend is closest. Ask gently and let them tell you what they are comfortable sharing. Write down what you learn while it is fresh.

Some of this belongs in the house notes you keep for the family. Our guide on house notes shows what is worth writing down.

Pets and routines

If they have been feeding a pet, ask about the food, the times, and any medication. Ask whether the pet is settled with them, and whether they are willing to keep helping for a short while. You do not have to decide everything today.

If the pet needs a new home, the guide on their pets need a home covers the practical steps.

What can wait

You do not need to sort the whole house or answer every question in the first week. Getting the key back and hearing what they know is enough for now. The rest can follow once you have had a chance to rest and talk to the family.

If the neighbour offers to keep helping, you can say yes to small things and leave the bigger decisions for later.

A few things to note down

  • The neighbour's name and how to reach them
  • Every key, fob, remote and code they hold, and whether it has been returned
  • Anything they told you about the house, the pets or the routines
  • Whether they are willing to help again, and with what

If you are the one holding the key

If you are reading this because you hold a neighbour's key, the same steps work in reverse. Offer the key back, say what you know, and ask what would help. It is a kindness to make the first move.

For the wider picture of the first days, see the first 48 hours. And if you are putting your own affairs in order, you can note who holds a spare key in your envelope, so your family is not left guessing.